I can normally
only write when I’ve drank a lot of coffee and dipped a lot of biscuits in said
coffee but the current weather is making me switch off from anything remotely
warm. I’m currently on week four of being off sick from work and having had an
operation twelve days ago which has resulted in an infection following that
operation, I’m really struggling with the heat.
Actually, I’m
really struggling with everything right
now. I hadn’t driven or been in my car for three weeks and when I finally
ventured behind the wheel, I discovered a bag containing a half-drunk fruit
smoothie in it. Let’s just say pineapple, banana and coconut repeatedly warmed
to the point of boiling in a place with a distinct lack of air absolutely stinks.
Because I’ve
been poorly, I’m bored. When I realised I was going to be off sick for a long
time, I splashed out on a load of original British drama box sets which were
polished off within a week. Now that the weather is glorious, everyone is
rejoicing and firing up the barbecues whilst I huddle in front of my fan and
sob because I have a temperature from my infection and the heat is killing me.
I’ve also
resorted to type and started re-watching Friends.
I say “re-watching”. What I actually mean is I broke my usual comfort blanket
of watching the show over and over on Comedy Central while I was watching my
box sets and now I’ve gone back to the norm. During one of my many freezing
cold baths lately, I read an article on Buzz Feed about Friends and what the
writer described as the “catalogue of errors” presented by the show.
While I don’t
necessarily agree that the show hosts a “catalogue of errors”, I do agree that
there are several mistakes, mostly continuity based, which I’ve picked up on
over the years. I’m not so bothered about the really basic filming errors, some
of which resurface on social media every few years. These errors range from the
apartment door number changing to a different actress filling in for Monica
when the camera isn’t focused on her to the actress who played Joey’s agent,
Estelle, also multi rolling as a midwife who delivers Ben.
The majority of
these tiny errors were most likely teething problems, which arose from the show
being very new and the fact that the writers, directors and producers had no
idea just how popular the show would be. As a writer, I’m more interested in
how the storyline itself has crumbled with too many tiny errors. Plot holes, if you will. How can you write
something and forget you wrote it? Hell, I can still quote my way through a
play I wrote six years ago.
Maybe I’m just sad. Anyway, I digress.
Firstly, let’s
take a look at the age of the characters. Ross and Monica are brother and
sister, therefore we know there is at least nine months age difference between
them. Yet if we think about the flashback episodes, we see Ross and Chandler at
college while Monica and Rachel are still at high school. Therefore, I think it’s
pretty safe to say there’s at least one year between the Gellar siblings,
although it’s most likely more. So, in the episode where Rachel turns thirty,
why are all the Friends aged thirty (Phoebe aside) with Rachel seemingly being
the youngest?
In fact, if we
cast our minds back to the earlier series, Ross says he is 29 years old on three
separate occasions: in series three, four and five. Ironically, his birthday
changes throughout the series. When Gunther asks Rachel when her birthday is,
Ross chimes in with his birthday, which is in December. But when Joey and Ross
are in the hospital after Ross punches Joey, he says his birthday is in
October.
Ironically, the
same thing happens with Phoebe. In series three, when talking to Frank Jnr, Phoebe
says that her birthday is February 16th (I remember so specifically as
this is my sister’s birthday), yet in the ninth series, Phoebe’s birthday
dinner is on Halloween.
Similarly, in
the episode where Monica fights for the bargain wedding dress, she says her
wedding is being held on May 15th. We know that on the morning of
her wedding, Rachel discovers she is pregnant. Presumably, she is around four
to five weeks at this point, perhaps a little further on maybe. It’s fair to
assume that Rachel conceived in April, roughly, which would mean her due date
would be approximately January. That’s all well and good until we remember that
when Rachel was towards the end of her pregnancy, she and Ross were attending a
hospital appointment and she says “it is 100 degrees outside”. Really? In New
York in January?
Also, on that
note, when Rachel and Phoebe met Dr Green for dinner and he grills Rachel about
his first grandchild “not being a bastard”, she reassures him by saying she has
a wedding booked for February 2nd. So, was the phantom wedding
intended for when Emma was a month old? Or was this a mystical pregnancy that lasted
a year and a half?
Speaking of
Rachel’s pregnancy, when she’s in hospital after giving birth and Monica spies
the engagement ring allegedly given to her by Joey, alarm bells should’ve rang
for Monica as this is the same bloody ring that Ross used to propose to Emily.
Perhaps she just didn’t recognise it, although she grew particularly attached
to this specific ring and put Emily off wearing it by informing her that it was
inside a duck’s colon for days. Or maybe their grandmother had several
expensive looking engagement rings knocking around, despite the fact that when
she moved to America, she had just the one ring and “the clothes on her back”,
implying that she was very poor. Ah well. Maybe Monica is just forgetful.
Let’s move back
to Ross for a second. In the first series, the guys make quite a big deal out
of the fact that Ross has only slept with one woman: Carol. Yet, if we fast
forward to the Thanksgiving episode featuring Brad Pitt, we discover that he in
fact slept with an elderly librarian when he was in college. As he met Carol in
college, we can only assume that either he was dishonest in the first series
(possible – he seemed embarrassed when people found out about Mrs Altman so
maybe he lied to avoid losing face) or he cheated on Carol, the woman he was
with for eight years, married and had a child with.
If it’s the
latter, it takes a whole new glance at Ross as a person. Sleeping with the girl
from the copy place was meant to be a one-off thing that was so out of
character for Ross but if he repeatedly cheats on every significant partner he’s
had, sorry but it makes him a wanker. The alternative is that the writers
forgot about the earlier confession that he had only slept with Carol and
therefore, it falls into the ever-increasing category of “continuity errors”.
Still on the “Rossatron”,
it’s crazy how throughout the series, he maintains that he has an allergy to
shellfish, yet he has no objectons to gobbling down those crab cakes when the
shit hits the fan.
Moving swiftly
forwards to Rachel and Chandler. How many times did those guys meet “for the
first time”? We know they met at the Geller’s during Thanksgiving on two
consecutive years but we also see them meet at a college party where they end
up kissing, yet apparently are totally unaware of each other. Let’s not forget
that they meet again “for the first time” in the first episode where Rachel
runs out on her wedding. It’s possible that as time has passed, she wouldn’t
know who Chandler was (maybe) but then to back up this third meeting by saying
in her potential maid of honour speech that she met Chandler for the first time
when he was a “twenty-five-year-old”.
No. No, you didn’t.
Speaking of
Rachel, her surname repeatedly changes how it’s spelled throughout the series.
We see her name listed as Rachel Green in the credits to the show, which is
corroborated when Rachel has Rachel Green written on the top of Emma’s first
birthday cake. However, it’s spelled as Greene on her office door at
Bloomingdales and also on her invitation to Ross’ wedding.
Let’s move on
to Ross and Monica’s parents: Jack and Judy Geller. In the episode where Jack
gives Monica his Porsche, we hear that there were suspicions that Judy couldn’t
conceive. The doctors then referred to Ross, who was conceived unexpectedly, as
a “medical marvel”. This is also mentioned in another episode where Ross
explains that doctors thought “she was baron”. Yet when Chandler and Monica
meet Jack and Judy for lunch following their engagement and Jack talks about
how he proposed to Judy, he explains that he’d gotten Judy pregnant and he
still wasn’t sure how it happened. Okay. So far, so good. But then Judy says “your
dog used my diaphragm as a squeeze toy”.
Hang on a
minute. If medical practitioners believed she had no hope of getting pregnant,
why did she use contraception? Without going into too much detail, I’m aware
that certain methods of contraception also act as something else e.g. the
contraceptive pill can help with periods etc. But a diaphragm is a complicated
little bugger that you have to put in and out of yourself each time you want to
have sex. Which would imply that, as the diaphragm was Judy’s preferred method
of protection, she perhaps hadn’t been told she wasn’t able to conceive. Which means
the whole “medical marvel” gag was total bullshit.
Bearing the Gellers
in mind, remember little Ben Geller? Sorry, Ben Geller-Willitt-Bunch, to be
exact. He didn’t turn up to his own father’s wedding, yet was present at both
his mother’s and his aunt and uncle’s. Now, I have my own theory on this. Ross’
wedding was in London, therefore a long way to travel for a young child. He
would’ve needed accompanying and presumably the person to do that would be his
parent and maybe it was just a bit awkward for either Carol or Susan to come
along to Ross’ wedding, not to mention costly. So why couldn’t Ross be responsible
for him? Or, failing that, his own grandparents?
In fact, Ben’s
role in the series deteriorated massively. In the earlier series, he was at
Ross’ apartment – and even Monica’s apartment – all the time. Ross had him
overnight and even begged Carol and Susan to let him have Ben for longer than
just one night. Yet towards the end of the series, we hardly see him at all and
we never once see Ben meeting his younger sister, Emma.
Right. Monica
and Chandler. When Monica puts the Thanksgiving turkey on her head and dances
for Chandler, he laughs and unexpectedly tells her that he loves her. It’s
clear that this is the first time, as Monica is astonished and says “you said
you love me. I can’t believe it”. Yet later on when Phoebe has rumbled their
budding relationship, Chandler declares his love for Monica by saying “I’m in
love with Monica. That’s right. I love her. I. LOVE. HER”.
Yet Monica,
overhearing this conversation from where she’d hid in the bathroom, is
astonished once again that Chandler has said he loves her.
I’m willing to let
this one slide though, as it’s clear that the turkey time was obviously blurted
out unexpectedly and the time with Phoebe, he obviously intended to say it.
Moving on to
Joey: did anybody notice that the amount of his sisters kept changing? He tells
Chandler that his mother “gave birth to six kids”, yet in another episode he
says he has seven sisters, which would mean there are actually eight of them. I
guess it’s possible that two of the kids were adopted, which means Mrs Tribbani
did only give birth to six kids, but it seems a little farfetched and unlikely.
It also annoyed
me that when Phoebe announced her engagement, Joey proposes a toast but doesn’t
know the name of her fiancé. Which would be all well and good – well, no, it
would be completely crap if your best mate didn’t know your fiancé’s name –
except Joey was the one who introduced them to each other! Admittedly, Joey
didn’t actually know Mike as it was a
total long shot that there was someone named Mike in close proximity to him
when he shouted out “Mike?” in the coffee house but evidently, he did know his
name. He’d even been on holiday with Joey, for goodness sake.
This one isn’t
so much a continuity error but more of a complaint. Personally, it felt that
the writers grew tired of thinking of interesting storylines and character development
for Joey towards the end of the show, as his character went from “dim but sweet”
to “bordering on serious learning difficulties”. Come off it. A fully-grown man
who, when presented with very basic French read out in one word sentences,
repeats gobbledegook back? It was cringeworthy.
And in series
nine, he explains that he can’t use air quotations correctly, which is weird
because he uses them throughout the series. Example: when Rachel is grilling
him over Monica and Chandler’s new secret relationship, he says “Monica and
Chandler are making love” and uses air quotations accurately. At times, it felt
as though the writers were so focused on Ross and Rachel towards the end that
Joey’s character was so dumbed down that it became unfunny and insulting
towards the character.
On this note, I
felt that the writers lacked inspiration with Phoebe too. She went from being a
ditsy hippie who cleansed people’s auras and gave a huge sum of money to a
homeless lady (not to mention being a surrogate for her brother) to being
downright insulting and nasty. “Really? Chandler?” and “Don’t even get me
started on Chandler” springs to mind. If one of my best friends was so
unnecessarily rude about my husband – who also happens to be one of their best
friends – I’d cut her out.
In line with
this, can we just talk about Phoebe’s dismissive attitude when Rachel confesses
that she kissed another girl when she was in college? Phoebe is so convinced
that it just “isn’t like” Rachel, which is odd considering Phoebe watched
Rachel kiss Monica for a whole minute in a bid to win back their apartment.
Finally, the
biggest curveball of them all – Erica unexpectedly giving birth to twins. It’s
ludicrous, outrageous perhaps, that a woman would be carrying twins without
realising it, unless of course she’s opted out of having any ultrasounds. But
we know that Erica did have an
ultrasound that Monica and Chandler gazed at proudly. Come on. You’re telling
me that a medical expert who performs ultrasounds day in, day out, didn’t pick
up on two babies on that scan? Particularly because they were clearly aware that Erica was carrying twins, as
Erica explains that a midwife told her that “both heartbeats are really strong”.
The only
possible explanation is that her initial ultrasound was very early on when
perhaps the second baby couldn’t be detected and that, as she’d decided to give
the baby up for adoption, she chose not to have any more scans? Possible but
very unlikely.
Regardless, I will
still continue to watch Friends and love it for all of eternity. It’s quite
literally the best comfort blanket a girl can have.